Smart MarketerSMART MARKETER LIVE

SMART MARKETER LIVE 2026 · DAY 2 TAKEAWAYS

5 New BFCM Plays to Make 2026 Your Best Black Friday Yet

John Grimshaw & Molly Pittman

Updated 2026-10-27 · 1 processed session

Strengthen your Black Friday Plan with better seasonal timing, a clearer offer comparison and messages matched to buying motives. John and Molly’s session adds five practical plays; the Coach helps you apply them inside the existing Planner using your own numbers.

01 / John Grimshaw, Molly Pittman5 New BFCM Plays to Make 2026 Your Best Black Friday Yet

2026-10-21 · Black Friday · BFCM · Q4 planning · Offer economics · Gifts with purchase · Seasonal lead capture · Email segmentation · Customer acquisition cost

Strengthen your Black Friday Plan with better seasonal timing, a clearer offer comparison and messages matched to buying motives. John and Molly’s session adds five practical plays; the Coach helps you apply them inside the existing Planner using your own numbers.

Download slides (PDF)

PUT THIS SESSION TO WORK

Welcome to John and Molly’s BFCM session. Let’s use these five plays to strengthen your Black Friday Plan. If you already have a plan, we’ll build on it.

Match the phase, offer and message to how customers buy, then judge the result using your own economics.

01

Plan for several demand windows

Gift, occasion and self-purchase demand need different timing and messages. Compare new-customer acquisition cost and your chosen profit measure by phase, with consistent definitions. Use your own economics to decide where to acquire customers and where to focus on profitable existing demand.

02

Add value before deepening the discount

Compare a deeper discount with a relevant gift, bundle, shipping benefit, access or delivery certainty. Evaluate the actual cost and contribution per order, then test demand; a cheaper incentive is not automatically a better offer.

03

Keep the paths that already work

Layer seasonal and deadline messages onto proven creative and destinations. Cold buyers may need explanation and proof; warm audiences may need a faster offer path. Keep budget decisions tied to actual performance.

04

Match the popup and welcome to the season

Update the creative, the reason to subscribe and the follow-up together. Tag the seasonal audience and deliver the offer they expected. Compare submit rates and downstream performance over clear, comparable windows.

05

Segment by why people buy

Use real order and customer evidence to propose a few buying motives. Match each to a message, value modifier and phase. Motives inferred by AI remain hypotheses until supported by evidence.

Would you like to strengthen your calendar, compare a gift with a deeper discount, or build a seasonal signup and email path?

Open a choice to see the first question and what you’ll create. Continue the work in your connected Coach.

Strengthen my Black Friday calendarA phase calendar with a clear objective, evidence, offer, owner and next action.

Find where each offer, audience and seasonal phase belongs in your current plan.

Useful inputs

  • Approved Offer Profile and Persona Profile
  • Existing Black Friday Plan or visible checkpoint, when available
  • Confirmed year, market and timezone
  • Phase-level spend, new customers and consistently defined profit if available
  • Inventory and team capacity

Work through it

  1. Reuse the attendee’s existing Black Friday Plan, approved Offer Profile and Persona Profile, decisions and checkpoint. If context is missing, complete the shared business-context approval flow. Ask one question at a time. This activity is a module of the existing Black Friday Planner, not a second competing plan.
  2. Use the BFCM metrics toolkit’s phase worksheet. Start with early promotion, BFCM, delivery cutoff and post-holiday windows, adapting dates and phases to this business rather than copying the historical chart.
  3. For each phase record buying motive, offer, new-customer spend/count, profit definition and days. Calculate CAC only with matched acquisition spend and new customers; normalize profit per day when periods differ. Keep missing inputs unknown.
  4. Propose scale, harvest or a limited test as a working objective based on economics, inventory and capacity. The speaker’s $80/$38 costs and 2× profit/day case are not thresholds. A lower CAC does not establish higher profit.
  5. Layer relevant seasonal messages onto proven destinations. Keep subscriber terms and delivery promises accurate. Assign the next feasible changes to the existing calendar.
  6. Update the same Black Friday Plan section and checkpoint, preserve other decisions, and offer three concrete implementation choices. If no plan exists, use start_black_friday_plan to establish the same plan without repeating answered intake. Keep business data in the host. Do not launch campaigns, spend, publish or send messages.

If inputs are missing: Without phase data, draft the calendar with provisional objectives and one focused evidence task. Continue useful message or asset planning.

Your working document

  • Existing plan checkpoint
  • Phase / dates / buyer motive
  • Objective and evidence
  • Offer and destination
  • Metrics, unknowns and review rule
  • Owner / deadline / next action

Complete when: The attendee chooses a phase objective and confirms the next useful action; unresolved economics stay marked.

Compare a gift with a deeper discountAn offer comparison and gift checklist added to your Black Friday Plan.

Put both offers through the same cost calculation before choosing a test.

Useful inputs

  • Approved Offer Profile and Persona Profile
  • Existing Black Friday Plan or visible checkpoint, when available
  • Eligible basket at list price
  • Current and proposed discount
  • Gift cost delivered and extra handling
  • Other per-order variable costs for each option
  • Stock and usable qualifying basket

Work through it

  1. Reuse the attendee’s existing Black Friday Plan, approved Offer Profile and Persona Profile, decisions and checkpoint. If context is missing, complete the shared business-context approval flow. Ask one question at a time. This activity is a module of the existing Black Friday Planner, not a second competing plan.
  2. Use the BFCM metrics toolkit calculator or its Markdown formulas. Keep the same eligible basket and currency. Separate the deeper-discount option from the current discount plus gift.
  3. Use known gift cost and scenario-specific other variable costs. Never replace missing costs with zero. Compare remaining value after discount and gift first; calculate contribution on the supplied scope only when all included costs are explicit.
  4. Explain slide 8’s $300 basket: 25% gives $75 off; 20% gives $60 off plus a gift costing about $10. That leaves $5 more before other cost differences. The $50 retail value is not the gift’s cost. The spoken example uses a different cost; neither is an attendee default.
  5. Complete landed cost, perceived value, existing demand, inventory and threshold checks. Keep stock and demand assumptions separate from the arithmetic. Set a test and review rule using contribution and conversion evidence when available.
  6. Update the same Black Friday Plan section and checkpoint, preserve other decisions, and offer three concrete implementation choices. If no plan exists, use start_black_friday_plan to establish the same plan without repeating answered intake. Keep business data in the host. Do not launch campaigns, spend, publish or send messages.

If inputs are missing: If gift or operating costs are missing, show the known discount difference, flag the gap and draft a gift shortlist or offer message while gathering costs.

Your working document

  • Offer A / offer B
  • Inputs and currency
  • Cost basis and missing costs
  • Per-order comparison
  • Gift audit and inventory
  • Test / owner / review rule

Complete when: The attendee has a scoped comparison, gift feasibility checklist and one chosen next test or evidence task; unknowns are visible.

Build my seasonal signup and email pathA seasonal capture brief, three motive hypotheses and first message drafts within your Black Friday Plan.

Turn one buying motive into a relevant popup and welcome sequence.

Useful inputs

  • Approved Offer Profile and Persona Profile
  • Existing Black Friday Plan or visible checkpoint, when available
  • Current popup and welcome flow
  • Approved live offer and dates
  • Aggregate purchase or customer evidence
  • Subscriber terms and inventory constraints

Work through it

  1. Reuse the attendee’s existing Black Friday Plan, approved Offer Profile and Persona Profile, decisions and checkpoint. If context is missing, complete the shared business-context approval flow. Ask one question at a time. This activity is a module of the existing Black Friday Planner, not a second competing plan.
  2. Choose up to three evidence-backed motive hypotheses and the relevant phase. Do not upload customer identifiers or pretend the Coach has access to an email account.
  3. Select one priority segment and draft seasonal popup creative/copy, reason to subscribe, tagging rule and a matching welcome message. Keep product proof available and consent/offer terms accurate.
  4. Use the toolkit’s measurement worksheet: record form views and submissions, sent/delivered denominator, attributed revenue, attribution window, dates and audience scope. Compare like with like; do not infer causation from different seasonal audiences.
  5. Give subscribers an appropriate separate path. Draft the next message and implementation checklist. The 2.68%/6.36% and 8–85× RPR cases are not forecasts or goals.
  6. Update the same Black Friday Plan section and checkpoint, preserve other decisions, and offer three concrete implementation choices. If no plan exists, use start_black_friday_plan to establish the same plan without repeating answered intake. Keep business data in the host. Do not launch campaigns, spend, publish or send messages.

If inputs are missing: Without customer data, label motive segments as hypotheses and draft one proposed message for approval. Keep outcome estimates blank.

Your working document

  • Buyer motive / evidence / unknowns
  • Offer and phase
  • Popup draft
  • Tag and welcome message
  • Subscriber handling
  • Measurement and comparison limits
  • Implementation next step

Complete when: The attendee confirms a priority motive, popup/welcome drafts and a clear measurement and implementation next step.

These activities feed into the existing Black Friday Planner. We reuse your approved business context and plan, ask one question at a time, and carry the result into implementation. The metrics toolkit is a Coach-created companion. Coaching paths and output templates are Coach-designed applications. This guide does not submit or store answers.

Read all takeaways ↓ · Open session resources ↓ · You can also ask the Coach a question about the session.

Questions about the session

Is this another Black Friday Planner?

No. This is the session’s teaching and resource page. Its activities strengthen the existing Black Friday Plan: phase decisions go into the calendar, gift economics into the offer brief, and seasonal capture and segment decisions into the campaign work. That integration is a Coach-designed application.

Talk · 40:02–40:21; Slides

Does a gift always beat a discount?

No. Compare actual costs, stock, demand and conversion. A higher remaining amount per order does not prove that more customers will buy or that total profit will rise.

Talk · 15:12–20:27; Slides; Slides

Should I send all paid traffic to the holiday page?

The session argues for preserving proven destinations and matching the path to the audience. Cold buyers may need product proof that a fast holiday page omits. Test with comparable traffic.

Talk · 20:27–25:24; Slides; Slides

Explore the full session index · 6 entries

All 37 nonempty transcript paragraphs and all 20 slides reviewed. Locations refer to transcript blocks. Personal details, audience asides and stage logistics omitted. Page numbers match the attendee PDF.

Key takeaways

  1. Plan for several demand windows

    Gift, occasion and self-purchase demand need different timing and messages. Compare new-customer acquisition cost and your chosen profit measure by phase, with consistent definitions. Use your own economics to decide where to acquire customers and where to focus on profitable existing demand.

    Talk · 4:17–9:33; Talk · 9:33–14:11; Slides; Slides; Slides; Slides

  2. Measure the whole offer cost

    Reconcile paid prices, compare-at markdowns and stacked discounts before calculating the real price reduction. Account for gift and shipping costs separately; a clean discount field does not capture the entire offer cost.

    Talk · 14:11–15:12; Talk · 15:12–20:27; Slides; Slides

  3. Add value before deepening the discount

    Compare a deeper discount with a relevant gift, bundle, shipping benefit, access or delivery certainty. Evaluate the actual cost and contribution per order, then test demand; a cheaper incentive is not automatically a better offer.

    Talk · 15:12–20:27; Slides; Slides

  4. Choose a gift the business can support

    Check landed cost, perceived value, current full-price demand, stock and a practical qualifying basket. Preserve margin and inventory, and avoid thresholds customers cannot reasonably reach with useful products.

    Talk · 15:12–20:27; Slides

  5. Keep the paths that already work

    Layer seasonal and deadline messages onto proven creative and destinations. Cold buyers may need explanation and proof; warm audiences may need a faster offer path. Keep budget decisions tied to actual performance.

    Talk · 20:27–25:24; Slides; Slides; Slides

  6. Match the popup and welcome to the season

    Update the creative, the reason to subscribe and the follow-up together. Tag the seasonal audience and deliver the offer they expected. Compare submit rates and downstream performance over clear, comparable windows.

    Talk · 25:24–29:38; Slides; Slides

  7. Segment by why people buy

    Use real order and customer evidence to propose a few buying motives. Match each to a message, value modifier and phase. Motives inferred by AI remain hypotheses until supported by evidence.

    Talk · 29:38–32:05; Slides; Slides

  8. Plan around subscribers and stock

    Give subscribers offers that respect their existing deal, and check stock before committing to seasonal promises. Use broad and segmented sends for appropriate jobs; small-segment revenue per recipient is not a universal performance target.

    Talk · 32:05–36:27; Slides

  9. Choose a few changes and put them to work

    Pick two or three useful changes, assign an owner and date, and keep moving into drafts and implementation checks. The Coach can carry these decisions into your existing Black Friday Plan.

    Talk · 39:28–40:02; Talk · 40:02–40:21; Slides

Resources from the session

RUN YOUR OWN NUMBERS

BFCM metrics toolkit — calculator, chart guide and worksheets

Why use it: Translate the graphs into decisions: compare a gift with a deeper discount, examine phases separately and measure seasonal capture fairly.

Get started: Read the chart guide, enter your own costs, then bring the result into your existing Black Friday Plan.

Open the toolkit →

Coach-created companion based on this session. Inputs stay in your browser; download your calculation before leaving.

FROM THE SPEAKER

BFCM metrics worksheet (Markdown)

Why use it: Work through the numbers with your Coach and keep the assumptions with your plan.

Get started: Download and fill in only known values. Keep unknown costs blank and preserve the measurement definitions.

Visit website →

Editable companion with the same chart interpretation, formulas and blank planning tables.

SESSION HANDOUT

Session slides (PDF)

Why use it: See the original charts and examples.

Get started: Use pages 5–6 for phases, 8–9 for gift economics, 11–14 for destinations and capture, and 17 for subscriber and segment considerations.

Download PDF →

20 attendee pages, original numbering, without speaker notes or hidden content.

RUN YOUR OWN NUMBERS

Omnisend — speaker-shared offer

Why use it: Explore the email/SMS and segmentation platform discussed in the session if it fits your seasonal messaging needs.

Get started: Review features and current terms before considering a switch. The Planner and toolkit work without buying or connecting Omnisend.

Open the toolkit →

The official destination was checked on October 21, 2026 and advertises 50% off the first three months with code SMART. Slide 20 also advertises migration in five days at no extra charge. Confirm eligibility, scope and current terms with Omnisend.

Examples from the session

Slide 8 compares a $300 list-price basket at 25% off ($75 discount) with 20% off ($60 discount) plus a gift costing about $10. The second option preserves $5 before other cost differences. This is illustrative arithmetic, not proof of conversion or total profit. Slides; Talk · 15:12–20:27

The phase case reports new-customer cost around $80 during BFCM and $38 in late December, plus about 2× New Year gross profit per day versus BFCM. These are one brand’s reported results; attribution, allocation and underlying data are not supplied. Slides; Talk · 9:33–14:11

The popup case shows 2.68% versus 6.36% submit rate and roughly $37,000 attributed revenue over three months versus fourteen days. Different windows and seasonal traffic prevent treating this as a controlled causal comparison. Slides; Talk · 25:24–29:38

Context to keep in mind

  • The official agenda title differs from the deck title, Five Proven Plays to Have Your Best Q4 Yet. Molly introduces John; John delivers the substantive teaching. Automated Unknown Speaker labels do not identify each voice.
  • Historical case figures are speaker-reported. Raw datasets, confidence estimates and complete attribution/cost definitions were not supplied. The demand chart is conceptual, not a numerical forecast.
  • Slide 8 assumes about $10 gift product cost; the spoken example uses about $6. Use your own landed and handling costs. Slide 9 suggests a threshold just above AOV; the delivered talk qualifies this with basket practicality.
  • Slide 11 does not label the unit for its 2.16–2.30, 2.15, 1.94–2.00 and 1.61 destination figures. Do not assert that these are conversion percentages or use them as thresholds.
  • Slide 17 reports 8–85 times revenue per recipient for small segments in one brand. The transcript has a garbled number. Use the slide’s range only as a reported case with unknown attribution and audience comparability, not an expected lift.
  • The metrics toolkit is a Coach-created application, not a speaker-supplied workbook. It does not recreate missing chart datasets. Sponsor offers and platform capabilities require checking current terms; no migration or integration is performed by the Coach.