# BFCM metrics toolkit

**Based on teaching from John Grimshaw & Molly Pittman** · Smart Marketer Live 2026 · October 21, 2026

A Coach-created companion to *5 New BFCM Plays to Make 2026 Your Best Black Friday Yet*. Use these tools inside your existing Black Friday Plan. The original slides and the Coach’s calculations are identified separately.

[Original slides (PDF)](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/slides/john-molly-bfcm-five-plays.pdf) · [Interactive calculator](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/resources/bfcm-metrics-toolkit.html) · [Session takeaways](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/takeaways/john-molly-bfcm-five-plays.html)

## Put it to work

Use Smart Marketer Live Coach. Strengthen my existing Black Friday Plan with John Grimshaw and Molly Pittman’s BFCM session. Reuse my approved business context and decisions. Help me choose the most useful next improvement: phase planning, gift-versus-discount economics, or seasonal signup and email. Ask one question at a time.

## Read the charts

### Demand shapes · [Slides 5](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/slides/john-molly-bfcm-five-plays.pdf#page=5)

**What it shows:** Gift-led, occasion-led and self-purchase demand peak at different points in the season. The attention-cost curve illustrates pressure around Black Friday.

**Keep in mind:** This is a conceptual chart; the underlying daily data is not supplied. It cannot forecast your demand, CPM or budget.

**Apply it:** Map your own purchase motives and delivery cutoffs to phases. Compare actual acquisition costs and contribution within each.

### Scale versus harvest · [Slides 6](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/slides/john-molly-bfcm-five-plays.pdf#page=6)

**What it shows:** One brand reports about $80 new-customer cost during BFCM, about $38 in late December, and about 2× New Year gross profit per day versus BFCM.

**Keep in mind:** These are historical case figures. Acquisition allocation and gross-profit definitions are not provided. Gross profit is not net profit, and cheap CAC alone does not establish profitable scale.

**Apply it:** Use matched new-customer spend/count and a consistent profit definition. Compare profit per day when periods differ; include inventory and cash capacity before changing spend.

### Gift versus discount · [Slides 8](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/slides/john-molly-bfcm-five-plays.pdf#page=8)

**What it shows:** On a $300 list-price basket, 25% off costs $75. At 20% off, the discount is $60; a gift costing about $10 leaves $5 more before other cost differences.

**Keep in mind:** The gift’s $50 stated retail value is not its cost. The spoken illustration uses a different gift cost. Neither is a default for your business, and order economics do not prove conversion or total profit.

**Apply it:** Use actual landed gift cost, added handling, payment fees and other differences. Check stock, genuine perceived value and a practical qualifying basket using page 9.

### Creative layers and destinations · [Slides 10](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/slides/john-molly-bfcm-five-plays.pdf#page=10)

**What it shows:** Page 10 layers evergreen, seasonal and deadline creative. Page 11 shows lower reported destination figures for the holiday page than established pages; page 12 separates cold and warm paths.

**Keep in mind:** The layer widths are not budget percentages. Page 11 does not label the units, so do not call its figures conversion percentages or use them as targets. Different audiences and campaigns can explain the comparison.

**Apply it:** Keep useful product proof and proven routes. Compare equivalent traffic and outcomes, and adjust losing spend rather than treating “never paused” as an unconditional rule.

### Seasonal popup · [Slides 14](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/slides/john-molly-bfcm-five-plays.pdf#page=14)

**What it shows:** The case reports 2.68% evergreen versus 6.36% seasonal submit rate. About $37,000 attributed revenue is shown for three months versus fourteen days.

**Keep in mind:** The rate difference is 3.68 percentage points, about 137% relative increase—not 3.68% relative lift. Different windows, intent and traffic mean this is not a controlled causal result or a promised outcome.

**Apply it:** Record views and submissions with the same definitions. Use comparable dates, devices, traffic and attribution windows. Check downstream orders and economics as well as form completion.

### Revenue per recipient · [Slides 17](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/slides/john-molly-bfcm-five-plays.pdf#page=17)

**What it shows:** The deck reports 8–85× revenue per recipient for small segmented sends versus broad blasts in one brand. It also calls out subscriber terms and inventory.

**Keep in mind:** Do not read this as an expected lift or 885× from the transcript error. Small and broad audiences have different intent; the source does not supply the denominator or attribution settings. RPR is not incremental profit.

**Apply it:** Document whether recipient means sent, delivered or unique people; never mix them. Pair RPR with total revenue, audience size, costs, unsubscribes and comparable attribution windows.

## Gift-versus-discount worksheet

Use the same list-price eligible basket and currency for both options. Taxes are excluded. Keep unknown costs blank; enter zero only when verified.

| Input | Your value |
|---|---|
| Currency | |
| Eligible basket before discount | |
| A: deeper discount % | |
| B: current discount % | |
| B: landed gift cost per order | |
| B: extra handling cost per order | |
| A: all other variable costs per order | |
| B: all other variable costs per order | |
| Cost scope / data source / date | |

Landed gift cost includes costs to obtain and deliver the gift; do not count those costs again in other costs. Other variable costs should include the basket products, payment fees, fulfillment, shipping support, refunds/returns allowance and attributable acquisition cost where relevant. Record exclusions; do not call a partial calculation total profit.

- A discounted revenue = basket × (1 − A discount / 100).
- B discounted revenue = basket × (1 − B discount / 100).
- A remaining before other costs = A discounted revenue.
- B remaining before other costs = B discounted revenue − gift − extra handling.
- Difference = B remaining − A remaining; positive favors B on this limited cost basis.
- Scoped contribution A/B = respective remaining − respective other variable costs.
- If both contributions are positive, B orders required to match A contribution at fixed A volume = A contribution / B contribution × A orders. This is arithmetic, not a demand forecast.

A higher result per order does not prove contribution per visitor or total profit. Compare conversion and order volume under comparable conditions before naming a winner.

### Gift feasibility

- Landed cost and extra handling known?
- Credible perceived value and fit with the buyer?
- Avoid displacing a strong full-price seller?
- Enough stock for a stated demand scenario?
- A useful, reachable qualifying basket?

## Phase planning worksheet

Adapt these suggested phases to your confirmed dates, market and delivery cutoffs. Do not copy dates or cost targets from a historical chart.

| Phase | Dates / days | Buyer motive | Offer | Objective: scale / harvest / test | Evidence / unknowns | Owner / next action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Early promotion | | | | | | |
| BFCM | | | | | | |
| Delivery cutoff | | | | | | |
| Post-holiday | | | | | | |

For each phase collect: currency, acquisition spend, number of new customers, revenue basis, product costs, other variable costs, refunds treatment, profit definition and number of days. New-customer CAC = matched acquisition spend / new customers. Profit per day = the consistently defined profit measure / calendar days. A zero denominator gives no valid rate. Gross profit, contribution and net profit are different measures; label what you actually have.

## Capture and segment measurement worksheet

| Metric | A | B | Same definitions and scope? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dates / duration | | | |
| Audience / device / traffic source | | | |
| Form views | | | |
| Submissions | | | |
| Submit rate = submissions / views | | | |
| Sent / delivered / unique recipient definition | | | |
| Recipient count on that basis | | | |
| Attributed revenue and attribution window | | | |
| RPR = attributed revenue / chosen recipient count | | | |
| Orders / contribution / refunds | | | |
| Unsubscribes / complaints | | | |

Rate difference in percentage points = B% − A%. Relative increase = (B − A) / A; undefined when A is zero. A rate or revenue difference does not establish causation. Record concurrent offer changes and seasonal intent. Keep private customer identities out of shared comparisons.

## Update the existing plan

Carry phase decisions into the campaign calendar, offer calculations into the Offer Brief, and popup/segment work into the messaging and test sections. Preserve approved decisions. Choose one next task: draft the offer, build the phase calendar, or write the seasonal popup and welcome. Assign an owner and date; unresolved costs and feasibility remain open.
