Distinguish scaling a winner from reaching new people.
Small variations and diverse concepts serve different purposes. Judge diversity by the audience and message difference, not the file count.
SMART MARKETER LIVE 2026 · DAY 1 TAKEAWAYS
Ben Bennett
Create more useful ad ideas from a winner without confusing extra files with fresh concepts. Use five clear variables to decide what to change, who the new ad should reach and what the test can teach you.
2026-10-20 · Ad creative · Creative diversity · Persona · Angles · Creative testing
Create more useful ad ideas from a winner without confusing extra files with fresh concepts. Use five clear variables to decide what to change, who the new ad should reach and what the test can teach you.
PUT THIS SESSION TO WORK
Create more useful ad ideas from a winner without confusing extra files with fresh concepts. Use five clear variables to decide what to change, who the new ad should reach and what the test can teach you.
Small variations and diverse concepts serve different purposes. Judge diversity by the audience and message difference, not the file count.
Style changes the visual treatment; format changes how the argument is composed or presented. Both can be varied without replacing the core offer.
Value proposition explains how the offer helps; angle chooses where the story begins. They are distinct ways to create a new argument.
A new face alone is not necessarily a new audience strategy. Change the message for the intended customer while preserving useful parts of the winner.
Use style, format, value proposition, angle and persona to describe each concept and make the next test deliberate.
Open a choice to see the first question and what you’ll create. Continue the work in your connected Coach.
Identify the five variables behind a proven concept.
If inputs are missing: Keep missing evidence explicit. Ask for the smallest useful input, or prepare a labeled draft for the user to complete; do not invent account results, customer facts or platform behavior.
Complete when: The user has reviewed the proposed output, confirmed its assumptions and chosen a next step.
Develop meaningful variations from an existing ad.
If inputs are missing: Keep missing evidence explicit. Ask for the smallest useful input, or prepare a labeled draft for the user to complete; do not invent account results, customer facts or platform behavior.
Complete when: The user has reviewed the proposed output, confirmed its assumptions and chosen a next step.
Find where the current library repeats the same idea.
If inputs are missing: Keep missing evidence explicit. Ask for the smallest useful input, or prepare a labeled draft for the user to complete; do not invent account results, customer facts or platform behavior.
Complete when: The user has reviewed the proposed output, confirmed its assumptions and chosen a next step.
The activities below are Coach-designed applications of the reviewed teaching. Before personalizing them, reuse approved business context or gather the business name and website, prepare Offer and Persona Profiles, obtain approval of both, and then resume the chosen activity. Session summaries do not require intake. Coaching paths and output templates are Coach-designed applications. This guide does not submit or store answers.
Read all takeaways ↓ · You can also ask the Coach a question about the session.
Index of reviewed teaching from the supplied recordings. Repeated rotations are consolidated; attendee exchanges and private details are excluded.
Distinguish a scale variation, which iterates on a winner for a similar audience, from a diverse variation intended to reach a different audience.
Creative diversity is a spectrum. A small change may appeal to a slightly different person, while changing the intended customer can create a much larger difference.
Ben’s five variables, from his least to most impactful for diversity, are style, format, unique value proposition, angle and persona.
Style changes how the ad appears while keeping the other variables largely the same. For example, a polished studio product image and a casual photo at home can present the same message differently.
Format is the composition or presentation of the argument. A side-by-side comparison and a person holding two products can express the same comparison in different formats.
The unique value proposition describes how the product delivers the transformation. Different functional benefits or an emotional explanation can emphasize different reasons to value the same offer.
Angle is the entry point into the transformation story. The ad can begin with the desired benefit, the current problem or another relevant part of that story.
Document the angle, format, style and value proposition of a winning ad before changing the persona. Change deliberately so you can understand which variable created a meaningful difference.
Changing the person on screen without changing the message may be closer to a scale variation than a substantially different audience strategy. How the message relates to people matters.
When changing the persona, preserve as much of the working foundation as makes sense. Avoid replacing everything with an unrelated audience and losing the basis for comparison.
Treat iteration as an experiment: control what you can so the resulting comparison answers the question you intended.
Small variations and diverse concepts serve different purposes. Judge diversity by the audience and message difference, not the file count.
Style changes the visual treatment; format changes how the argument is composed or presented. Both can be varied without replacing the core offer.
Value proposition explains how the offer helps; angle chooses where the story begins. They are distinct ways to create a new argument.
A new face alone is not necessarily a new audience strategy. Change the message for the intended customer while preserving useful parts of the winner.
Use style, format, value proposition, angle and persona to describe each concept and make the next test deliberate.
A studio product image and a casual at-home image can carry the same words and offer while testing a different visual style. Talk · 06:41