# 5 Things That Make a New Ad a New Ad — Takeaways

Updated 2026-10-27 · 1 processed session

Key lessons from the sessions, with practical ways to put them to work.

### Make it useful

Copy this prompt into your connected Smart Marketer Live Coach:

```text
Show me the takeaways for 5 Things That Make a New Ad a New Ad.
Speaker: Ben Bennett
Topics: Ad creative, Creative diversity, Persona, Angles, Creative testing.
```

Then choose one idea to apply to your business.


<a id="expert-roundtable-12"></a>

## 5 Things That Make a New Ad a New Ad

**Speaker:** Ben Bennett · 2026-10-20

**Topics:** Ad creative, Creative diversity, Persona, Angles, Creative testing

Create more useful ad ideas from a winner without confusing extra files with fresh concepts. Use five clear variables to decide what to change, who the new ad should reach and what the test can teach you.

### Welcome

Welcome. This session with Ben Bennett can help you create more useful ad ideas from a winner without confusing extra files with fresh concepts. Use five clear variables to decide what to change, who the new ad should reach and what the test can teach you.

Create more useful ad ideas from a winner without confusing extra files with fresh concepts. Use five clear variables to decide what to change, who the new ad should reach and what the test can teach you.

- **Distinguish scaling a winner from reaching new people.** — Small variations and diverse concepts serve different purposes. Judge diversity by the audience and message difference, not the file count.
- **Separate style from format.** — Style changes the visual treatment; format changes how the argument is composed or presented. Both can be varied without replacing the core offer.
- **Change the reason to believe or the story’s entry point.** — Value proposition explains how the offer helps; angle chooses where the story begins. They are distinct ways to create a new argument.
- **Make persona changes meaningful.** — A new face alone is not necessarily a new audience strategy. Change the message for the intended customer while preserving useful parts of the winner.
- **Write down the five variables before iterating.** — Use style, format, value proposition, angle and persona to describe each concept and make the next test deliberate.

Which of these would be most useful for your business?

- **Map my winning ad** — A five-variable creative map and one promising next change.
- **Create three distinct concepts** — Three creative briefs with their changed variables made explicit.
- **Audit my creative variety** — A creative inventory and a prioritized gap to test.

You can also ask a question or read all takeaways below.

The activities below are Coach-designed applications of the reviewed teaching. Before personalizing them, reuse approved business context or gather the business name and website, prepare Offer and Persona Profiles, obtain approval of both, and then resume the chosen activity. Session summaries do not require intake.

### Choose an action

These coaching paths and output templates are Coach-designed applications of the session. Use them with your connected Coach; this guide does not store your answers.

#### Map my winning ad

Identify the five variables behind a proven concept.

**You leave with:** A five-variable creative map and one promising next change.

**First question:** Which ad do you want to understand before making more versions?

**Useful inputs:**

- Approved offer and persona
- Ad copy, transcript or screenshots
- Evidence for calling it a winner

**Coaching sequence:**

1. Reuse the approved offer and persona; confirm which product, audience and decision this activity concerns.
2. Describe its style, format, value proposition, angle and persona from the actual content.
3. Ask the user to confirm ambiguous interpretations.
4. Identify one variable to change and the audience difference it is intended to create.

**If inputs are missing:** Keep missing evidence explicit. Ask for the smallest useful input, or prepare a labeled draft for the user to complete; do not invent account results, customer facts or platform behavior.

**Complete when:** The user has reviewed the proposed output, confirmed its assumptions and chosen a next step.

**Your working document:**

- **Source ad:** To complete with your Coach.
- **Five-variable map:** To complete with your Coach.
- **Uncertainties:** To complete with your Coach.
- **Proposed change and audience:** To complete with your Coach.

#### Create three distinct concepts

Develop meaningful variations from an existing ad.

**You leave with:** Three creative briefs with their changed variables made explicit.

**First question:** Which new customer or motivation should your next concepts speak to?

**Useful inputs:**

- Approved offer and persona
- Winning-ad map
- Customer evidence
- Available production formats

**Coaching sequence:**

1. Reuse the approved offer and persona; confirm which product, audience and decision this activity concerns.
2. Use approved persona evidence to identify a relevant difference in motivation or audience.
3. Draft three concepts, each with an explicit variable change and retained foundation.
4. Distinguish scale variations from stronger diversity hypotheses; do not claim Meta will treat them a particular way.

**If inputs are missing:** Keep missing evidence explicit. Ask for the smallest useful input, or prepare a labeled draft for the user to complete; do not invent account results, customer facts or platform behavior.

**Complete when:** The user has reviewed the proposed output, confirmed its assumptions and chosen a next step.

**Your working document:**

- **Concept:** To complete with your Coach.
- **Audience/motivation:** To complete with your Coach.
- **Variable changed:** To complete with your Coach.
- **What stays:** To complete with your Coach.
- **Hook and execution brief:** To complete with your Coach.

#### Audit my creative variety

Find where the current library repeats the same idea.

**You leave with:** A creative inventory and a prioritized gap to test.

**First question:** Can you share a small set of ads you consider different concepts?

**Useful inputs:**

- Approved offer and persona
- Current ad set or descriptions
- Available results

**Coaching sequence:**

1. Reuse the approved offer and persona; confirm which product, audience and decision this activity concerns.
2. Map each ad across the five variables.
3. Group near-identical scale variations and identify genuinely different arguments.
4. Choose a gap in style, format, value proposition, angle or persona and define a controlled comparison.

**If inputs are missing:** Keep missing evidence explicit. Ask for the smallest useful input, or prepare a labeled draft for the user to complete; do not invent account results, customer facts or platform behavior.

**Complete when:** The user has reviewed the proposed output, confirmed its assumptions and chosen a next step.

**Your working document:**

- **Creative map:** To complete with your Coach.
- **Repeated concepts:** To complete with your Coach.
- **Audience/message gaps:** To complete with your Coach.
- **Next comparison:** To complete with your Coach.

### Session index

Index of reviewed teaching from the supplied recordings. Repeated rotations are consolidated; attendee exchanges and private details are excluded.

#### Scale variations versus diverse concepts

Distinguish a scale variation, which iterates on a winner for a similar audience, from a diverse variation intended to reach a different audience.

[Talk · 01:52](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json)

#### Diversity as a spectrum

Creative diversity is a spectrum. A small change may appeal to a slightly different person, while changing the intended customer can create a much larger difference.

[Talk · 03:44](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json)

#### Five-variable hierarchy

Ben’s five variables, from his least to most impactful for diversity, are style, format, unique value proposition, angle and persona.

[Talk · 04:43](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json)

#### Style: visual treatment

Style changes how the ad appears while keeping the other variables largely the same. For example, a polished studio product image and a casual photo at home can present the same message differently.

[Talk · 06:41](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json)

#### Format: presentation of the argument

Format is the composition or presentation of the argument. A side-by-side comparison and a person holding two products can express the same comparison in different formats.

[Talk · 07:15](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json)

#### Unique value proposition

The unique value proposition describes how the product delivers the transformation. Different functional benefits or an emotional explanation can emphasize different reasons to value the same offer.

[Talk · 08:04](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json)

#### Angle: where the story begins

Angle is the entry point into the transformation story. The ad can begin with the desired benefit, the current problem or another relevant part of that story.

[Talk · 10:39](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json)

#### Map the winner before changing persona

Document the angle, format, style and value proposition of a winning ad before changing the persona. Change deliberately so you can understand which variable created a meaningful difference.

[Talk · 14:36](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json)

#### A new face versus a new message

Changing the person on screen without changing the message may be closer to a scale variation than a substantially different audience strategy. How the message relates to people matters.

[Talk · 15:35](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json)

#### Preserve a useful foundation

When changing the persona, preserve as much of the working foundation as makes sense. Avoid replacing everything with an unrelated audience and losing the basis for comparison.

[Talk · 14:11](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json)

#### Controlled iteration

Treat iteration as an experiment: control what you can so the resulting comparison answers the question you intended.

[Talk · 15:05](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json)


### Key takeaways

1. **Distinguish scaling a winner from reaching new people.** — Small variations and diverse concepts serve different purposes. Judge diversity by the audience and message difference, not the file count. ([Talk · 01:52](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json); [Talk · 03:44](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json))

2. **Separate style from format.** — Style changes the visual treatment; format changes how the argument is composed or presented. Both can be varied without replacing the core offer. ([Talk · 06:41](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json); [Talk · 07:15](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json))

3. **Change the reason to believe or the story’s entry point.** — Value proposition explains how the offer helps; angle chooses where the story begins. They are distinct ways to create a new argument. ([Talk · 08:04](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json); [Talk · 10:39](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json))

4. **Make persona changes meaningful.** — A new face alone is not necessarily a new audience strategy. Change the message for the intended customer while preserving useful parts of the winner. ([Talk · 15:35](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json); [Talk · 14:11](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json))

5. **Write down the five variables before iterating.** — Use style, format, value proposition, angle and persona to describe each concept and make the next test deliberate. ([Talk · 04:43](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json); [Talk · 14:36](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json); [Talk · 15:05](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json))

### Examples from the session

- A studio product image and a casual at-home image can carry the same words and offer while testing a different visual style. ([Talk · 06:41](https://smlcoach.smartmarketer.com/coaches/smart-marketer/reviewed-sources/expert-roundtable-12.json))

### Put it to work

Suggested by the Coach, based on this session:

- Coach suggestion: Choose one activity and use your approved offer and persona to make it specific.
- Coach suggestion: Confirm the evidence, owner and next review point before implementing a change.

### Context to keep in mind

- The ranking of variables is Ben’s framework and opinion, not a guaranteed hierarchy of performance.
- The recordings end as questions begin; no separate Q&A teaching is included.

---

These notes paraphrase the supplied session materials. Sources distinguish the delivered transcript from prepared slides. Slide citations open attendee PDFs. Transcript and worksheet links may require source access.
