Smart MarketerSMART MARKETER LIVE

SMART MARKETER LIVE 2026 · DAY 1 TAKEAWAYS

Which AI Project Should You Build Next?

Russ Henneberry

Updated 2026-10-27 · 1 processed session

Choose an AI project that supports your business priority, then turn it into a workflow you can build and test. Use Russ’s scorecard to compare ideas, decide where people should stay involved, and identify the next practical step.

01 / Russ HenneberryWhich AI Project Should You Build Next?

2026-10-20 · AI project selection · Growth × Readiness · Human judgment · Workflow planning

Choose an AI project that supports your business priority, then turn it into a workflow you can build and test. Use Russ’s scorecard to compare ideas, decide where people should stay involved, and identify the next practical step.

PUT THIS SESSION TO WORK

Let’s find the AI project that will make the biggest difference for your business.

Use Growth × Readiness to compare your ideas, decide what to automate or keep human, and map a practical first test. Choose the activity that fits where you are now.

01

Start with one business priority and five ideas.

Choose whether the priority is getting more customers, selling more to existing customers, or selling to them more often. List five tasks and score how much each would help that priority.

02

Score readiness by the weakest link.

Score Growth from 1–5. Score five readiness checks from 1–5: clear steps, low-stakes errors, ready data, connected tools and manageable volume. Readiness is the lowest check, not the average; multiply Growth × Readiness to get GR.

03

Choose Automate, Assist a human, or Keep human.

A high score does not automatically mean a task should be automated. Keep people involved where trust, relationships, judgment or service create value. If AI will assist a person, score that combined workflow.

04

Pick the best suitable project and define success.

Choose the highest GR among suitable Automate or Assist projects. Check the weakest readiness factor, break ties with the business priority, and name a success metric before moving ahead.

05

Map the steps, owners and approvals before building.

Walk one real example through the workflow with the people who own it. Identify inputs, tools, human decisions and feedback loops. Use an AI interview to fill gaps in the plan, then test and improve the workflow.

What would you like to put to work?

Open a choice to see the first question and what you’ll create. Continue the work in your connected Coach.

Choose my next AI projectA completed Growth × Readiness scorecard, one selected project and a success metric.

Compare five ideas against your business priority and choose a suitable first project.

Useful inputs

  • Approved offer and persona
  • One business priority
  • Five candidate tasks or help identifying them
  • Evidence about how each task works today

Work through it

  1. Confirm one business priority using the approved offer and persona; help the user list five candidate tasks.
  2. For each task, ask for the evidence behind Growth: 1 = nice to have, 3 = meaningful improvement, 5 = critical bottleneck. Use 2 or 4 between anchors.
  3. Score clear steps, low-stakes errors, ready data, connected tools and manageable volume from 1–5: 1 = major barrier, 3 = work needed, 5 = ready. Explain each score and confirm it with the user.
  4. Calculate R as the minimum of the five readiness checks, then GR = Growth × R. Show the math; do not average readiness or invent a score for unknown inputs.
  5. Choose A = Automate, S = Assist a human, or H = Keep human based on the value of trust, relationships, judgment and service. For S, score the AI + human version and recalculate if the design changes.
  6. Among suitable A or S projects, select the highest GR, check its weakest factor, and break ties with the business priority. A high GR never overrides a Keep human decision.
  7. Confirm the selected project and a measurable success metric, then offer to map the workflow.

If inputs are missing: Help brainstorm when there are fewer than five ideas. Keep uncertain scores blank and ask for evidence; do not rank incomplete rows as if verified. Do not copy the Northstar example scores or metric into the user’s business.

Your working document

  • Business priority
  • Five tasks: Growth; five readiness checks; R = minimum; GR = G × R; A/S/H; rationale
  • Unknowns and weakest readiness factor
  • Selected suitable A/S project and tie-break rationale
  • Success metric
  • Next step

Complete when: The user has confirmed the scoring, human involvement, chosen project and success metric.

Make an AI idea ready to buildA readiness plan with the weakest check, a human role and concrete steps to resolve the gaps.

Find what is holding one promising project back and decide how AI and a person should share the work.

Useful inputs

  • One candidate task
  • Business priority
  • Current process, data and tools
  • People affected by the outcome

Work through it

  1. Connect the task to the approved offer, persona and chosen business priority. Score Growth from 1–5 using 1 = nice to have, 3 = meaningful improvement and 5 = critical bottleneck; explain the evidence.
  2. Walk through a real example and assess all five readiness checks, using the scorecard’s 1–5 anchors and recording evidence for each score.
  3. Compare Automate, Assist and Keep human. Preserve human responsibility where trust, relationships, judgment or service matter; do not apply a numerical automation cutoff.
  4. For Assist, assess the AI + human version. Set R to the lowest check and calculate GR only when all inputs are known.
  5. For each weak or unknown check, identify the missing requirement, a responsible person and evidence that would show it is ready.
  6. Agree on the next readiness improvement or keep the task human. Re-score only after the facts or proposed workflow change.

If inputs are missing: Use an interview to uncover missing steps or dependencies. Unknown data access, tool capability or error consequences stay unresolved until confirmed.

Your working document

  • Task and growth priority
  • Five readiness checks with evidence
  • Automate / Assist / Keep human and reason
  • R and GR, or unresolved inputs
  • Weakest factor and improvement plan: requirement, owner, evidence
  • Next review

Complete when: The user has agreed on human involvement and the next step to resolve the limiting readiness factor.

Map my AI workflowA workflow map and build brief with owners, inputs, outputs, approvals and a first test.

Turn your chosen project into clear steps, tool handoffs and human approval points.

Useful inputs

  • A selected project and success metric
  • The people doing the work
  • A real example of the task
  • Current tools and known access

Work through it

  1. Confirm the selected project and its Automate or Assist decision using the approved business context; if it is Keep human, preserve that decision.
  2. Walk one real example from the initial brief through the result with its owners. Ask one focused question at a time where the process is unclear.
  3. Map each step with an owner, input, output and tool. Separate AI work, human work and handoffs; mark unconfirmed integrations as dependencies.
  4. Add explicit human decision points and what happens when work is rejected. In the supplied ad example, the media buyer approves launch and a rejection returns to asset revision; adapt that pattern to the user’s task.
  5. Connect results to the next iteration. Capture what worked, what failed and why, then propose an instruction or workflow revision to test.
  6. Write a build brief, get the user to confirm it, and define one small first test and how to assess its outcome.

If inputs are missing: A rough description or partial diagram is enough. Interview for missing details; do not assume the user uses Northstar’s ad tools or has granted launch access.

Your working document

  • Goal and success metric
  • Workflow: step, owner, input, output, tool
  • Human decisions and revision routes
  • Missing details and access dependencies
  • Build brief
  • First test and feedback loop

Complete when: The user has checked the workflow, human approvals, unresolved dependencies and first test.

Your Coach will reuse your approved Offer Profile and Persona Profile. If those are missing, it will ask for your business name and website, help draft the profiles, and ask you to approve them before continuing your chosen activity. These activities apply Russ’s handouts and the reviewed closing excerpt to your business. Coaching paths and output templates are Coach-designed applications. This guide does not submit or store answers.

Read all takeaways ↓ · Open session resources ↓ · You can also ask the Coach a question about the session.

Questions about the session

Do I average the five readiness scores?

No. Readiness is the lowest of the five checks. Multiply that number by Growth. For example, G4 and checks 5, 4, 3, 5, 4 give R3 and GR12.

Worksheet

Does the highest score mean I should automate the task?

No. First decide Automate, Assist or Keep human. Rank suitable Automate and Assist projects; a Keep human task is not made eligible by a high score. The filled example gives both refill reminders and VIP thank-you notes a GR of 20, but keeps the thank-you notes human.

Worksheet; Worksheet

How do I score a project where AI assists a person?

Score the AI + human version of the task. The person’s role is part of the design being assessed, rather than scoring a fully autonomous version and adding review afterward.

Worksheet

How should I choose between two suitable projects with the same score?

Use the business priority to break the tie and inspect the weakest readiness factor. Record the chosen project and its success metric.

Worksheet

Do I need a polished diagram before starting?

No. Russ describes using a partial map or a picture of the process as the starting point for an AI interview to fill in the missing details.

Talk · 00:25; Talk · 04:40; Talk · 05:37

Do I need to use the tools shown in Northstar’s map?

The map is an ad-creation example showing tools by stage, ownership and approvals. The Coach can help map the tools and handoffs for your own task; the example does not establish that those integrations already exist in your business.

Worksheet; Talk · 03:54; Talk · 04:40

Explore the full session index · 28 entries

This index combines three owner-supplied, one-page prepared handouts with the reviewed closing transcript excerpt. Worksheet references point to the PDFs; transcript references open selected, paraphrased teaching with attendee exchanges omitted. It does not imply that the full presentation was recorded.

Choose the business priority

Choose one of three growth priorities and list five tasks to compare.

Worksheet

Score growth impact

Growth anchors are 1 = nice to have, 3 = meaningful improvement, 5 = critical bottleneck; use 2 or 4 between anchors.

Worksheet

Check five readiness factors

Score clear steps, low-stakes errors, ready data, connected tools and manageable volume. Readiness anchors are 1 = major barrier, 3 = work needed, 5 = ready. Use 2 or 4 between anchors.

Worksheet

Calculate Growth × Readiness

R is the lowest readiness check, not the average. GR = Growth × R. G4 with checks 5,4,3,5,4 gives R3 and GR12.

Worksheet

Decide Automate / Assist / Keep human

Keep people where trust, relationships, judgment or service create value. Score the AI + human version for Assist.

Worksheet

Choose a suitable project and metric

Circle the highest GR among suitable Automate or Assist projects, examine the weakest factor, and break ties with the business priority. Write the project and success metric.

Worksheet

Northstar filled scorecard

Prepared example: ad angles G3/R4/GR12/S; bundle offers G3/R4/GR12/S; refill reminders G5/R4/GR20/A; product FAQs G3/R3/GR9/S; VIP thank-you notes G4/R5/GR20/H. These are example judgments, not measured outcomes.

Worksheet

Northstar selected project and metric

The example prioritizes selling more often to existing customers and selects refill reminders. It proposes 60-day repeat-purchase rate versus a holdout. Equally scored VIP thank-you notes remain Keep human.

Worksheet

Step 1: Set the test brief

Media buyer: Define the product, audience, offer, spend and goal.

Worksheet

Step 2: Gather evidence

AI + automation: Gather reviews, support tickets, orders and past ads.

Worksheet

Step 3: Draft five angles

AI + automation: Include customer insight, proof and a citation for each angle.

Worksheet

Step 4: Choose three angles

Creative strategist: Rank relevance and refine the positioning.

Worksheet

Step 5: Build test packs

AI + automation: Prepare hooks, copy and creative briefs.

Worksheet

Step 6: Produce test ads

Creative strategist: Assemble the assets and check the landing-page fit.

Worksheet

Step 7: Approve the launch

Media buyer: Use the “OK to launch?” decision: yes advances to launch; no returns to step 6 for revision.

Worksheet

Step 8: Launch the test

Media buyer: Set the spend cap and tracking, then publish.

Worksheet

Step 9: Join the results

AI + automation: Join spend and orders by angle and ad ID.

Worksheet

Step 10: Plan the next test

Media buyer: Keep, revise or stop; update the angle log and return to the brief for the next weekly test.

Worksheet

Tools and ownership in the ad example

The media buyer owns budget, approvals and the AI/automation lane; the creative strategist owns positioning and assets. Steps 1–3 use Shopify, Gorgias and Meta Ads Manager; 4–8 use Google Docs, Higgsfield, Google Drive and Meta Ads Manager; 9–10 use Meta Ads Manager, Shopify and Google Sheets. These are the supplied example’s tools.

Worksheet

Map steps and responsibilities

Map the workflow step by step before building it. Identify the people, AI steps and tools involved. A swim lane map is one way to show who does what; another clear process map can serve the same purpose.

Talk · 00:25

Start the ad workflow with a brief

In the ad-creation example, a media buyer and creative strategist first define what is being sold, the offer, spend and goal. They then collect customer language from reviews, support interactions and research to inform the advertising.

Talk · 01:18

Draft angles after research

Drafting ad angles comes after establishing the brief and gathering customer language.

Talk · 02:14

Human creative review

AI can help gather research and propose ad angles, but the creative person should review the proposals and decide which are worth advancing. The reviewer should explain what they like or dislike and why.

Talk · 02:19

Revise instructions from feedback

Use specific feedback about the proposed angles to revise the instructions or skill that produced them, such as explaining when ideas are repetitive and need more variety.

Talk · 03:23

Identify tools for each step

Break the workflow into small steps and identify which tools each step needs to access. Evaluation includes explaining why an output does or does not work, so the workflow's instructions can be improved.

Talk · 03:54

Use a rough map to start an interview

Capture the process map and ask the AI to interview you for the missing details needed to write a specification. A partially completed map can be the starting point for that interview.

Talk · 04:40

Fill gaps before building and testing

When you have described as much of the desired workflow as you can, ask the AI to interview you about the remaining details. Use the answers to prepare the build, then test the workflow and fix it as you go.

Talk · 05:37

Evaluate and improve the workflow

Improve the workflow through testing and specific feedback about what worked and what did not. An evaluation interface can provide a structured way to record the output and the reason it needs improvement.

Talk · 06:29

Key takeaways

  1. Start with one business priority and five ideas.

    Choose whether the priority is getting more customers, selling more to existing customers, or selling to them more often. List five tasks and score how much each would help that priority.

    Worksheet

  2. Score readiness by the weakest link.

    Score Growth from 1–5. Score five readiness checks from 1–5: clear steps, low-stakes errors, ready data, connected tools and manageable volume. Readiness is the lowest check, not the average; multiply Growth × Readiness to get GR.

    Worksheet

  3. Choose Automate, Assist a human, or Keep human.

    A high score does not automatically mean a task should be automated. Keep people involved where trust, relationships, judgment or service create value. If AI will assist a person, score that combined workflow.

    Worksheet; Worksheet

  4. Pick the best suitable project and define success.

    Choose the highest GR among suitable Automate or Assist projects. Check the weakest readiness factor, break ties with the business priority, and name a success metric before moving ahead.

    Worksheet

  5. Map the steps, owners and approvals before building.

    Walk one real example through the workflow with the people who own it. Identify inputs, tools, human decisions and feedback loops. Use an AI interview to fill gaps in the plan, then test and improve the workflow.

    Worksheet; Talk · 04:40; Talk · 05:37; Talk · 06:29

Resources from the session

SESSION HANDOUT

Growth × Readiness scorecard (PDF)

A one-page worksheet for comparing five potential AI projects.

Why use it: Choose a project that supports your business priority and is practical to implement.

Get started: List five tasks, score growth and the five readiness checks, choose A/S/H, then name your priority and success metric.

Download PDF →

One-page PDF supplied by Russ for this session.

SESSION HANDOUT

Filled scorecard example (PDF)

Northstar Daily Supplements’ prepared comparison of five AI opportunities.

Why use it: See why a high-scoring task can still stay human and how a project earns priority.

Get started: Compare the refill-reminder and VIP thank-you-note rows. Use the reasoning as a guide; score your own business from its evidence.

Download PDF →

One-page PDF supplied by Russ for this session.

SESSION HANDOUT

Northstar ad workflow map (PDF)

A ten-step example with people, AI tasks, tools, launch approval and a feedback loop.

Why use it: Turn a selected idea into a workflow with clear ownership and handoffs.

Get started: Walk one real example of your task with its owners, then map the steps, human decisions, tool access and next test.

Download PDF →

One-page PDF supplied by Russ for this session.

Examples from the session

The prepared Northstar Daily Supplements scorecard prioritizes selling more often to existing customers. Refill reminders score G5 × R4 = 20 and are selected for automation. VIP thank-you notes also score 20 but are marked Keep human, so the score alone does not decide what to automate. The proposed success metric is 60-day repeat-purchase rate versus a holdout; the handout does not report a measured result. Worksheet

The Northstar ad workflow uses AI to gather evidence and draft five angles, a creative strategist to choose three, and a media buyer to approve the launch. A rejected launch returns to asset revision. Results feed the next weekly test. This is an example workflow to adapt, not a requirement to use the same tools or run ads. Worksheet

Context to keep in mind

  • The recording covers only the closing workflow-planning portion. The owner-supplied scorecards and workflow map now supply the prepared project-selection framework and diagram; they are cited separately from the delivered transcript.
  • The Northstar materials are prepared examples. Their scores, tool choices and proposed metric are not results or facts about your business.
  • The map is a planning example, not an executable automation. Tool access, integrations and launch permissions must be confirmed for your own workflow.