Know your real discount rate.
Start with one sales channel and calculate discounts divided by gross sales over the same trailing 12 months. Then check for markdowns and incentives that do not appear in the discount line.
SMART MARKETER LIVE 2026 · VIP DAY TAKEAWAYS
Kyle Yeoman
Kyle Yeoman explains how Groove reduced habitual discounting, adjusted its operating costs and rebuilt its product pages to improve profitability. The practical starting points are to measure discount dependence, review promotions against contribution dollars and strengthen the case for buying at full price. His Q&A preserves a role for selective promotions, bundles and seasonally appropriate incentives.
2026-10-19 · profitability · discounting · quality of revenue · contribution margin · promotions · product pages · conversion · Amazon A+ · leadership
Kyle Yeoman explains how Groove reduced habitual discounting, adjusted its operating costs and rebuilt its product pages to improve profitability. The practical starting points are to measure discount dependence, review promotions against contribution dollars and strengthen the case for buying at full price. His Q&A preserves a role for selective promotions, bundles and seasonally appropriate incentives.
PUT THIS SESSION TO WORK
Let’s turn the lessons into a more profitable business: understand what discounting costs, improve your ability to sell at full price, and choose promotions deliberately.
Start with one sales channel and calculate discounts divided by gross sales over the same trailing 12 months. Then check for markdowns and incentives that do not appear in the discount line.
Compare a promotion with what the business would likely have earned without it. Include the post-promotion dip, discount depth, product costs and advertising cost; higher revenue alone does not establish a profitable promotion.
Start with one important product page. Use customer evidence and product knowledge to explain the value, demonstrate the product and answer buying objections. A stronger sales argument can support full-price conversion.
Open a choice to see the first question and what you’ll create. Continue the work in your connected Coach.
Find your reported discount rate, identify less-visible incentives and choose one useful test.
If inputs are missing: Provide a ready-to-fill audit and explain the exact data needed. Continue mapping incentives while figures are missing. Mark estimates as estimates and never substitute Groove’s numbers for the attendee’s data.
Complete when: The channel, date range and reported rate are clear or explicitly pending; the incentive map separates costs and overlap; one measurable experiment is ready for the attendee to consider.
Compare a recent sale with the contribution the business likely would have generated without it.
If inputs are missing: Draft the review table and list the missing inputs. Calculate only supported components. If the baseline is unreliable, show scenarios and say the incremental result is uncertain rather than manufacturing a precise answer.
Complete when: The attendee can see observed inputs, modeled assumptions, comparable contribution dollars, the post-promo effect and a clear next decision.
Build a stronger reason to buy before reaching for a deeper discount.
If inputs are missing: If the page or reviews are unavailable, create a page brief with a proposed outline, a founder interview and a proof-gathering checklist. Label draft assumptions and keep unsupported claims out of copy.
Complete when: One product and audience are defined; the sales argument, proof needs and page outline are usable; an accountable owner and measurement approach are identified or marked to confirm.
Start with your own economics. Kyle’s Q&A makes room for selective promotions; the goal is to reduce dependence and improve the quality of revenue. If you are unsure where to start, begin with the discount audit. Coaching paths and output templates are Coach-designed applications. This guide does not submit or store answers.
Read all takeaways ↓ · Open session resources ↓ · You can also ask the Coach a question about the session.
No. In the Q&A, the host and Kyle explicitly distinguish habitual discount dependence from selective promotions. Kyle described two promotional windows, holiday bundles and a separate approach to Amazon.
Kyle said a low-discount seasonal business can keep incentives that work for its situation. He also suggested looking for ways existing customers could buy at other times. That answer was contextual, not a rule for every seasonal brand.
Kyle recommends testing it. Groove tried a 10% email incentive and shipping before removing offers whose conversion lift did not offset their cost. He suggested useful education as one possible alternative; the right result still depends on the business.
They can create economic costs even when they do not appear as a discount. Record actual product cost and incremental shipping or fulfillment, distinguish perceived gift value from cost, and check overlap. Kyle supports gifts or bundles when appropriate and cautions about making them always-on.
Talk · 44:32–44:54; Talk · 45:21–46:16; Talk · 50:19–50:36; Slide · 23
Kyle recommends the most capable senior person, informed by customer reviews and the founder’s product knowledge. The Coach can organize evidence and draft a brief; responsibility for the core judgment stays with that person.
The title and slides use the 3× headline. At 36:03 Kyle specifies net-profit percentage and says the improvement in absolute dollars was not quite as high. Preserve that distinction rather than reporting a precise threefold increase in profit dollars.
With a $100 price and $40 product cost, full-price contribution after 30% advertising is $30 per unit. At 30% off, collected revenue is $70 and advertising is $21, leaving $9. Matching $30 requires about 3.33 units: 233% additional units. This corresponds to roughly 133% additional net revenue, a different measure.
Slide numbers refer to the original PowerPoint order. Slide 38 is hidden in that file, so PDF page numbers after it are one lower.
Kyle defines quality partly by repeatability and describes a cycle of promotions, spikes, comparison pressure and deeper offers. Growth incentives can reward top-line volume while margin deteriorates.
Audit one channel first. Use discounts divided by gross sales for the same trailing 12 months. Compare-at markdowns may be absent from the reported discount line.
The presentation uses under 10%, 10%–20%, 20%–30% and 30% or above. Treat these as speaker heuristics; exact boundary conventions are clarified in the guide.
The illustration assumes a 30% discount, 60% full-price gross margin and advertising at 30% of collected revenue. It requires 233% extra units, not 233% extra net revenue.
Compare with an appropriate normal-sales baseline and include the period after a promotion. The sample’s negative incremental contribution is hypothetical.
Incentives in multiple funnel stages can accumulate. The speaker’s example is deliberately broad; examine actual order behavior and avoid double-counting costs.
Groove adjusted costs starting in the prior year and lowered discounting from January. Volume initially dropped substantially. The talk emphasizes financial preparation and leadership agreement rather than a universal overnight change.
Kyle describes redirecting time previously spent making and analyzing promotions into improving product education and sales pages.
The delivered talk mentions clearer style and color choices, useful product education, higher-quality imagery and demonstrations. A discounted accessory upsell remained; the new page was not entirely offer-free.
The first redesign was shipped without a controlled A/B test. Kyle then discusses testing important headlines and elements after establishing a stronger overall page.
Kyle keeps attribution comparable in his before/after CPA story and says the ad account was unchanged. The implication is to assess the site as well as traffic, not to claim advertising execution never matters.
Reported outcomes include more collected per unit and non-promotional growth. Celebrate the repeatable portion of revenue and interpret each metric on its own basis.
The spoken qualification is net-profit percentage; absolute profit dollars increased by a smaller factor. No exact dollar multiplier is supplied.
Kyle notes Groove sells durable products and needs first-order profitability. He encourages learning to sell at full price on an appropriate scope rather than copying every Groove decision.
Improve the underlying sales argument instead of relying on minor design changes. Price elasticity still matters; if demand vanishes, pricing itself may need review.
The talk reports a 42% conversion lift from improved Amazon A+ content. The channel has a different layout, but the product’s reasons to buy can carry across.
Kyle repeatedly frames the toolkit as a mental exercise and asks attendees to apply judgment to their own business. Closing networking remarks are indexed without republishing personal contact details.
Gifts and bundles can make sense; distinguish actual costs from list-value framing and avoid making every incentive always-on.
Groove retained two promotional windows and discussed a bundle for the coming holiday period. The forward-looking growth expectation is a forecast, not an achieved result.
Use product reviews and founder insight, with a capable senior owner directing the first rebuild rather than design by committee.
A contextual answer supports seasonal incentives where the existing discount exposure is low and the economics work; it does not establish a universal seasonal rule.
Test the conversion benefit against the incentive cost. Education can be an alternative to price incentives. Free shipping can still be used selectively.
Kyle defines quality partly by repeatability and describes a cycle of promotions, spikes, comparison pressure and deeper offers. Growth incentives can reward top-line volume while margin deteriorates.
Kyle defines quality partly by repeatability and describes a cycle of promotions, spikes, comparison pressure and deeper offers. Growth incentives can reward top-line volume while margin deteriorates.
Kyle defines quality partly by repeatability and describes a cycle of promotions, spikes, comparison pressure and deeper offers. Growth incentives can reward top-line volume while margin deteriorates.
Kyle defines quality partly by repeatability and describes a cycle of promotions, spikes, comparison pressure and deeper offers. Growth incentives can reward top-line volume while margin deteriorates.
Kyle defines quality partly by repeatability and describes a cycle of promotions, spikes, comparison pressure and deeper offers. Growth incentives can reward top-line volume while margin deteriorates.
Kyle defines quality partly by repeatability and describes a cycle of promotions, spikes, comparison pressure and deeper offers. Growth incentives can reward top-line volume while margin deteriorates.
Kyle defines quality partly by repeatability and describes a cycle of promotions, spikes, comparison pressure and deeper offers. Growth incentives can reward top-line volume while margin deteriorates.
Kyle defines quality partly by repeatability and describes a cycle of promotions, spikes, comparison pressure and deeper offers. Growth incentives can reward top-line volume while margin deteriorates.
Kyle defines quality partly by repeatability and describes a cycle of promotions, spikes, comparison pressure and deeper offers. Growth incentives can reward top-line volume while margin deteriorates.
Kyle defines quality partly by repeatability and describes a cycle of promotions, spikes, comparison pressure and deeper offers. Growth incentives can reward top-line volume while margin deteriorates.
Kyle defines quality partly by repeatability and describes a cycle of promotions, spikes, comparison pressure and deeper offers. Growth incentives can reward top-line volume while margin deteriorates.
Kyle defines quality partly by repeatability and describes a cycle of promotions, spikes, comparison pressure and deeper offers. Growth incentives can reward top-line volume while margin deteriorates.
Audit one channel first. Use discounts divided by gross sales for the same trailing 12 months. Compare-at markdowns may be absent from the reported discount line.
Audit one channel first. Use discounts divided by gross sales for the same trailing 12 months. Compare-at markdowns may be absent from the reported discount line.
The presentation uses under 10%, 10%–20%, 20%–30% and 30% or above. Treat these as speaker heuristics; exact boundary conventions are clarified in the guide.
The presentation uses under 10%, 10%–20%, 20%–30% and 30% or above. Treat these as speaker heuristics; exact boundary conventions are clarified in the guide.
The presentation uses under 10%, 10%–20%, 20%–30% and 30% or above. Treat these as speaker heuristics; exact boundary conventions are clarified in the guide.
The presentation uses under 10%, 10%–20%, 20%–30% and 30% or above. Treat these as speaker heuristics; exact boundary conventions are clarified in the guide.
The illustration assumes a 30% discount, 60% full-price gross margin and advertising at 30% of collected revenue. It requires 233% extra units, not 233% extra net revenue.
The illustration assumes a 30% discount, 60% full-price gross margin and advertising at 30% of collected revenue. It requires 233% extra units, not 233% extra net revenue.
Compare with an appropriate normal-sales baseline and include the period after a promotion. The sample’s negative incremental contribution is hypothetical.
Compare with an appropriate normal-sales baseline and include the period after a promotion. The sample’s negative incremental contribution is hypothetical.
Incentives in multiple funnel stages can accumulate. The speaker’s example is deliberately broad; examine actual order behavior and avoid double-counting costs.
Incentives in multiple funnel stages can accumulate. The speaker’s example is deliberately broad; examine actual order behavior and avoid double-counting costs.
Groove adjusted costs starting in the prior year and lowered discounting from January. Volume initially dropped substantially. The talk emphasizes financial preparation and leadership agreement rather than a universal overnight change.
Groove adjusted costs starting in the prior year and lowered discounting from January. Volume initially dropped substantially. The talk emphasizes financial preparation and leadership agreement rather than a universal overnight change.
Groove adjusted costs starting in the prior year and lowered discounting from January. Volume initially dropped substantially. The talk emphasizes financial preparation and leadership agreement rather than a universal overnight change.
Groove adjusted costs starting in the prior year and lowered discounting from January. Volume initially dropped substantially. The talk emphasizes financial preparation and leadership agreement rather than a universal overnight change.
Groove adjusted costs starting in the prior year and lowered discounting from January. Volume initially dropped substantially. The talk emphasizes financial preparation and leadership agreement rather than a universal overnight change.
Kyle describes redirecting time previously spent making and analyzing promotions into improving product education and sales pages.
Kyle describes redirecting time previously spent making and analyzing promotions into improving product education and sales pages.
The delivered talk mentions clearer style and color choices, useful product education, higher-quality imagery and demonstrations. A discounted accessory upsell remained; the new page was not entirely offer-free.
The first redesign was shipped without a controlled A/B test. Kyle then discusses testing important headlines and elements after establishing a stronger overall page.
Reported outcomes include more collected per unit and non-promotional growth. Celebrate the repeatable portion of revenue and interpret each metric on its own basis.
Reported outcomes include more collected per unit and non-promotional growth. Celebrate the repeatable portion of revenue and interpret each metric on its own basis.
The spoken qualification is net-profit percentage; absolute profit dollars increased by a smaller factor. No exact dollar multiplier is supplied.
Kyle notes Groove sells durable products and needs first-order profitability. He encourages learning to sell at full price on an appropriate scope rather than copying every Groove decision.
This slide is hidden in the PowerPoint. It asks attendees to understand their starting position; do not imply it was displayed live.
Kyle notes Groove sells durable products and needs first-order profitability. He encourages learning to sell at full price on an appropriate scope rather than copying every Groove decision.
Kyle notes Groove sells durable products and needs first-order profitability. He encourages learning to sell at full price on an appropriate scope rather than copying every Groove decision.
Kyle notes Groove sells durable products and needs first-order profitability. He encourages learning to sell at full price on an appropriate scope rather than copying every Groove decision.
Improve the underlying sales argument instead of relying on minor design changes. Price elasticity still matters; if demand vanishes, pricing itself may need review.
Improve the underlying sales argument instead of relying on minor design changes. Price elasticity still matters; if demand vanishes, pricing itself may need review.
Improve the underlying sales argument instead of relying on minor design changes. Price elasticity still matters; if demand vanishes, pricing itself may need review.
Improve the underlying sales argument instead of relying on minor design changes. Price elasticity still matters; if demand vanishes, pricing itself may need review.
The talk reports a 42% conversion lift from improved Amazon A+ content. The channel has a different layout, but the product’s reasons to buy can carry across.
The talk reports a 42% conversion lift from improved Amazon A+ content. The channel has a different layout, but the product’s reasons to buy can carry across.
Kyle repeatedly frames the toolkit as a mental exercise and asks attendees to apply judgment to their own business. Closing networking remarks are indexed without republishing personal contact details.
Closing contact and networking slide. Personal contact information is omitted from this guide.
Start with one sales channel and calculate discounts divided by gross sales over the same trailing 12 months. Then check for markdowns and incentives that do not appear in the discount line.
Compare a promotion with what the business would likely have earned without it. Include the post-promotion dip, discount depth, product costs and advertising cost; higher revenue alone does not establish a profitable promotion.
Start with one important product page. Use customer evidence and product knowledge to explain the value, demonstrate the product and answer buying objections. A stronger sales argument can support full-price conversion.
Repeated promotions can create sales spikes, tougher comparisons and pressure for deeper discounts. Kyle recommends celebrating non-promotional revenue growth and monitoring the margin beneath top-line growth.
Talk · 2:59–12:49; Talk · 34:54–36:03; Slides · 7–11; Slide · 35
Kyle’s illustration needs about 233% more units under specific assumptions: a $100 list price, $40 unit cost, 30% discount and ad spend equal to 30% of collected revenue. This is a directional model, not a universal threshold.
Welcome codes, cart offers, coupon exposure, loyalty offers, affiliate costs, markdowns and shipping subsidies can accumulate. Some are costs rather than reported discounts. Check stacking and order overlap before estimating the effect of changing them.
Groove reduced operating expenses before sharply lowering discounting and still experienced an initial volume drop. Leadership alignment helped it hold the course. This is a case-specific sequence, not a recommendation to halve every business’s costs or stop discounts overnight.
Kyle describes replacing a weak page before refining high-value elements. In the Q&A he recommends customer reviews, founder knowledge and a capable senior owner for the first rebuild. His point is to avoid marginal tests on a weak sales argument.
Talk · 32:18–34:50; Talk · 36:03–40:27; Talk · 47:06–47:58; Slides · 42–44
If the business sells on Amazon, adapt useful product education to its A+ content. Kyle also connects the same selling logic to retail, while recognizing that each channel has its own format.
The Q&A explicitly rejects a blanket never-discount rule. Groove retained two promotional windows, discussed holiday bundles and treated Amazon separately. Kyle advised testing welcome incentives and considering seasonality and the business’s actual economics.
At 36:03, Kyle clarifies that the roughly 3× result refers to net-profit percentage; the increase in absolute profit dollars was smaller. Use the official session title while preserving this qualification when discussing results.
RUN YOUR OWN NUMBERS
The Google Sheets toolkit Kyle shared so you can run the session’s calculations with your own business numbers.
Why use it: See how much extra volume a discount needs to pay off, whether a promotion improved contribution, and where everyday incentives may be reducing your margins. Use it before deciding which offers to keep, change or test.
What’s included:
Get started: Open the toolkit, choose File → Make a copy, and replace the sample inputs with your own numbers for one sales channel. Start with the tab that matches the decision you want to make.
Use the results as a thought exercise, not a forecast. The break-even result is extra units, not extra net revenue; check the assumptions and avoid counting overlapping incentives twice.
Groove reported an aggregate discount-rate change from 33.7% to 2.9%. This was part of a broader change involving operating costs, leadership alignment and product-page work. Talk · 2:59–6:30; Talk · 24:30–30:37; Slide · 29
Kyle reported a 61% improvement in conversion for the redesigned belt page and a 52% lower Meta CPA on the slide. He described the same seven-day click attribution and no ad-account changes. The first page replacement was not a controlled A/B test, so these are reported before/after outcomes rather than an isolated causal estimate. Talk · 30:42–34:50; Slides · 32–33
The deck reports 30% more collected per unit, 14% higher non-promotional revenue and 1% less ad spend. The transcript supports the emphasis on collections and evergreen revenue; these percentages use different measures and should not be recombined as if they share one denominator. Talk · 34:50–36:03; Slides · 34–35
The hypothetical promotion produces $45,000 of contribution during the sale versus $63,000 under the assumed baseline, plus a $12,600 post-sale shortfall: $30,600 less contribution in total. This is an illustrative incremental comparison, not a claim that Groove ran that promotion or that total accounting profit was negative. Talk · 21:12–22:36; Slide · 22; Worksheet
Kyle reported a 42% conversion increase after updating Amazon A+ content. This is a speaker-reported case result, not an expected lift for another business. Talk · 41:47–42:28; Slide · 47
The updated belt page still showed a targeted discounted accessory upsell. Kyle explained that its aggregate discount effect was smaller, reinforcing the difference between reducing dependence and removing every offer. Talk · 30:42–32:18; Slide · 32