Smart MarketerSMART MARKETER LIVE

SMART MARKETER LIVE 2026 · DAY 1 TAKEAWAYS

4 Levers of Acquisition

Josh Coffy

Updated 2026-10-27 · 1 processed session

Find the next acquisition move that fits your business’s actual constraint. Work through volume, profit per order, acquisition cost and repeat purchase instead of trying every tactic at once.

01 / Josh Coffy4 Levers of Acquisition

2026-10-20 · Customer acquisition · Offers · Order profitability · Repeat purchase

Find the next acquisition move that fits your business’s actual constraint. Work through volume, profit per order, acquisition cost and repeat purchase instead of trying every tactic at once.

PUT THIS SESSION TO WORK

Welcome. Josh Coffy’s four levers help you choose an acquisition move based on the constraint your business is facing.

Check the actual business constraint and acquisition measure before treating more spend as the next move.

01

Increase volume only when the relevant economics work.

Check the actual business constraint and acquisition measure before treating more spend as the next move.

02

Improve what an order contributes.

Review pricing, product entry points, offers, upsells and downsells. An offer includes value and positioning, not just a discount.

03

Choose more, better or new to address acquisition cost.

Examine channels separately and decide whether to expand working creative, improve execution or test a new approach.

04

Design the next purchase around the customer’s stage.

Test relevant follow-up and personal outreach in a manageable cohort, then learn before automating or expanding it.

Which useful next step would you like to work on?

Open a choice to see the first question and what you’ll create. Continue the work in your connected Coach.

Choose my next acquisition leverA diagnosis of volume, order profit, acquisition cost and repeat purchase with one chosen test.

A diagnosis of volume, order profit, acquisition cost and repeat purchase with one chosen test.

Useful inputs

  • Approved Offer Profile and Persona Profile
  • Relevant business information the user chooses to share

Work through it

  1. Use the approved offer and persona to keep this activity relevant to the selected business.
  2. Confirm the constraint and decision metric using available evidence.
  3. Walk through the four levers in the speaker’s order without assuming a universal target.
  4. Select one test with an owner, measurement period and decision criteria.

If inputs are missing: Ask one question at a time for missing information. Mark unknowns clearly; do not invent business facts, results or benchmarks.

Your working document

  • Current business constraint
  • Chosen acquisition metric and confirmed target
  • Four levers: evidence and open questions
  • Selected lever and proposed test
  • Owner, measurement window and decision criteria

Complete when: The user has reviewed the output, confirmed a practical next step and assigned an owner.

Strengthen my first-order offerA proposed offer test that improves value without defaulting to a deeper discount.

A proposed offer test that improves value without defaulting to a deeper discount.

Useful inputs

  • Approved Offer Profile and Persona Profile
  • Relevant business information the user chooses to share

Work through it

  1. Use the approved offer and persona to keep this activity relevant to the selected business.
  2. Separate the core value proposition from price and discount.
  3. Review entry product, price, offer structure and relevant add-ons.
  4. Choose one change and identify the order-economics evidence needed to judge it.

If inputs are missing: Ask one question at a time for missing information. Mark unknowns clearly; do not invent business facts, results or benchmarks.

Your working document

  • Current first-order offer and intended customer
  • Verified value and positioning
  • Pricing, entry-product and add-on options
  • Chosen offer variation
  • Order-economics evidence needed and test plan

Complete when: The user has reviewed the output, confirmed a practical next step and assigned an owner.

Plan a repeat-purchase testA small customer follow-up experiment suited to the buying journey.

A small customer follow-up experiment suited to the buying journey.

Useful inputs

  • Approved Offer Profile and Persona Profile
  • Relevant business information the user chooses to share

Work through it

  1. Use the approved offer and persona to keep this activity relevant to the selected business.
  2. Identify the customer stage and relevant next offer.
  3. Draft a useful personal check-in for an appropriate user-approved audience.
  4. Design a small manual test, record the response and compare repeat behavior before proposing automation.

If inputs are missing: Ask one question at a time for missing information. Mark unknowns clearly; do not invent business facts, results or benchmarks.

Your working document

  • Customer stage and relevant next purchase
  • User-approved audience and cohort size
  • Useful check-in draft
  • Manual process and owner
  • Response and repeat-behavior measures
  • Decision before expanding or automating

Complete when: The user has reviewed the output, confirmed a practical next step and assigned an owner.

These activities are Coach-designed applications of the reviewed teaching. Before personalizing them, reuse approved business context or gather the business name and website, draft Offer and Persona Profiles, and obtain approval of both. Summaries do not require onboarding. Coaching paths and output templates are Coach-designed applications. This guide does not submit or store answers.

Read all takeaways ↓ · You can also ask the Coach a question about the session.

Questions about the session

Is an offer the same thing as a discount?

No. A discount changes price; an offer also communicates the outcome, value, effort, timing and confidence behind the purchase.

Talk · 14:04; Talk · 15:01

Should the follow-up process be automated immediately?

The speaker recommends testing the process manually first, resolving the practical issues and then considering automation.

Talk · 23:04

Explore the full session index · 14 entries

Index of reviewed teaching from the supplied recordings. Repeated rotations are consolidated; attendee exchanges and private details are excluded.

Find the actual business constraint

Before choosing an acquisition tactic, check whether the business is constrained by acquisition, fulfillment, product development or operations.

Talk · 04:48

The volume lever

When acquisition economics meet the business’s target, volume is the first lever in the speaker’s framework. Define the relevant acquisition metric before increasing spend.

Talk · 07:08

Choose the relevant acquisition metric

Use the acquisition metric appropriate to the business, including new-customer acquisition cost when that is the decision-making measure.

Talk · 08:00

Improve profit per order

If profit per order is weak, work on the economics of an individual order. Pricing is one of the possible levers.

Talk · 09:45

Product, offer and add-on choices

Ways to improve the initial order include product entry points, offers, upsells and downsells. Choose the change that addresses the actual constraint.

Talk · 11:58

An offer is more than its price

An offer is broader than its price or discount. It includes the desired outcome, confidence in achieving it, time to value, effort and positioning.

Talk · 14:04

Discount dependence and positioning

Relying only on discounts can make volume dependent on sacrificing profit. Improving the offer and lowering acquisition cost are different parts of the framework.

Talk · 15:01

More, better or new

For an acquisition-cost problem, compare channels separately and consider whether to do more of what works, improve it, or test something new.

Talk · 16:39

Test a different creative or acquisition approach

Improvement can include more varied creative; new tests can explore different channels, funnels or offer approaches.

Talk · 17:30

The repeat-purchase lever

Repeat purchase is the fourth lever. The speaker places it after the earlier acquisition and order-economics checks because changing repeat behavior can require more substantial business work.

Talk · 19:55

Test personal outreach with a cohort

Test personal customer outreach with a manageable cohort rather than trying to contact everyone at once. Evaluate the effect before expanding the work.

Talk · 22:26

Test manually before automating

Test a process manually before optimizing or automating it.

Talk · 23:04

Match messaging to the buying stage

Adapt on-site messaging to the buyer’s stage. A returning prospect who has not purchased needs a different message from someone placing a later order.

Talk · 29:38

Use purchase history for the next offer

A customer’s previous purchase can help determine a relevant next offer, including a subscription offer where suitable.

Talk · 30:26

Key takeaways

  1. Increase volume only when the relevant economics work.

    Check the actual business constraint and acquisition measure before treating more spend as the next move.

    Talk · 04:48; Talk · 07:08; Talk · 08:00

  2. Improve what an order contributes.

    Review pricing, product entry points, offers, upsells and downsells. An offer includes value and positioning, not just a discount.

    Talk · 09:45; Talk · 11:58; Talk · 14:04; Talk · 15:01

  3. Choose more, better or new to address acquisition cost.

    Examine channels separately and decide whether to expand working creative, improve execution or test a new approach.

    Talk · 16:39; Talk · 17:30

  4. Design the next purchase around the customer’s stage.

    Test relevant follow-up and personal outreach in a manageable cohort, then learn before automating or expanding it.

    Talk · 19:55; Talk · 22:26; Talk · 23:04; Talk · 29:38; Talk · 30:26

Context to keep in mind

  • The order is the speaker’s diagnostic framework, not a universal financial benchmark.
  • The transcript mentions worksheets and a software resource, but no resource has been independently verified for this entry.
  • The second recording is a continuation of the first; it is consolidated here.